Butterfly Effect: Point Blank |
Shoot yourself |
Shoot Ashley |
Shooting Ashley is a sure Death flag for Chris (due to events later on) but will give you the “Fatal Grudge” trophy.
Butterfly Effect: Shoot yourself/ Do nothing
This seems to be the good option since you'll retain your great relationship level with Ashley. This will also ensure that she'll open the door for Chris, ensuring his survival when he's being chased by the wendigo.
Butterfly Effect: Shoot Ashley
This will permanently make Ashley distrust Chris, and during the critical scene when Chris was chased by the wendigo, Ashley won't open the door in the lodge, leaving Chris to his Death outside in the hands of the pursuing wendigo. This will unlock the trophy "Ashley Snaps"