Fortune Totems signifies a good fortune if you'll follow the suggested action in the playback scene. How you play will determine whether or not these prophecies come true. As you unlock Totems, "The Events of the Past" will become clear.
Fortune Totem #1
[Chapter 2] When Mike and Jess are going through the mine and right after the sudden QTE event when Mike was almost crushed by a mine cart, continue to the end of the tracks to find this totem.
Fortune Totem #2
[Chapter 5] As soon as Chapter 5 starts, once you're in control with Mike, walk toward the fountain then go to the left. The totem is found by the gate.
Fortune Totem #3
[Chapter 5] When controlling Matt and Emily, they'll go around the cable car station. After walking past a wooden walkway and stairs, Emily will go to the cliff to the right. Don't follow her immediately. Check the tree in the middle to find this totem.
Fortune Totem #4
[Chapter 8] Follow the tracks and you'll find this totem to the right, along the way.
Fortune Totem #5
[Chapter 10] After the scene with the hallucinating Josh, you’ll be controlling Sam with Mike accompanying you. Once in control, keep to the right so that you won’t miss the Fortune Totem #5 on the ground right before the ledge where you can drop off.
Fortune Totem #6
[Chapter 10] After regrouping with Josh in the mines, follow him until he stops at a fork and talks about Jesse. Go to the left and you should see the glimmer on the ground. Examine it to get a Fortune Totem.