Chapter 10: One Hour Until Dawn (Sam and Mike)

You’ll be controlling Josh for now. During the scenes, walk when you can then punch the pig’s head when prompted.

After the scene, you’ll be controlling Sam with Mike accompanying you. Once in control, keep to the right so that you won’t miss the Fortune Totem #5 on the ground right before the ledge where you can drop off. After getting the totem, keep walking to the left to find Beth’s Watch. (Twins Clue #19)

(Death Flag!) Backtrack to the ledge and drop down the water. Keep moving to the left and climb up the ledge left of the water wheel. You’ll find Hannah’s Journal (Twins Clue #20) there. This is a very important piece of clue and the last one in The Twins series of clues. If you didn’t miss any in the previous chapters, you’ll unlock the trophy “The Tale of the Two Sisters” after flipping through the pages and unlock the new Butterfly Effect. (Important Discovery)

Now go back to the water and head to the right this time. Climb up the next ledge and open the door to trigger a cutscene. Apparently, this is where you'll find the bodies of any of your killed friends. Otherwise, you'll only find the Stranger's body here. At the end of this cutscene, you’ll also be reunited with Josh.

After the scene, you’ll control Josh. Follow him until he stops at a fork and talks about Jesse. Go to the left and you should see the glimmer on the ground. Examine it to get a Fortune Totem. Regroup with Mike and follow him back to the water. Continue following Mike until a wendigo will pop up from the water and it will kill Josh if you didn’t find the journal earlier.