Magical Melody or Save the Homeland?

Click here for all our Harvest Moon: Magical Melody Questions

Magical Melody or Save the Homeland?

I have the game AWL and I herd that MM is a lor better. But I also own a PS2 and I herd that Save the Homeland is a more role-playing experience and who doesn't like RPGs? But I don't know how either game is like and it sounds like MM is better cause it still has that farming experience and stuff. I just want to know what you guys think. Which is better, MM or the StH?

Date of Question: Feb 9th 2008 | Question ID: 109432

DemonChild6 | Member | Joined: Feb 8th 2008
0 Posts | 2 Submissions

PRINT | TRACK | REPORT | ANSWER

ANSWERS

I like MM but I haven't played STH before so I can't compare

Pokemonboy1 | Member | Joined: Apr 27th 2007
22 Posts | 117 Submissions

Best Answer

I myself, like all of the HM series :]

MM is a great game, giving you many more options than the other games in the HM series. You get a wider selection when it comes to finding a husband/wife, you get to choose where you want to live, choose your own furniture,etc. Its fun, and will keep you entertained with is unique storyline. Overall, it's a great purchase.

STH also has the farming experiance as well, contrary to what you've been told. STH came out before AWL-MM so it doesnt have as much varriety when it comes to animals/crops, and the graphics arent as good considering it's an older game, but there are still many tasks that are rather enjoyable throught out the game to keep you satisfied. For being one of the older games of the HM series, STH is a rather good game, and in my opinion, is a good purchase as well. These are just my opinions, and in the end it is your decision upon to which game you will purchase. Hope I helped :]

bgfl529 | Member | Joined: May 20th 2006
7708 Posts | 375 Submissions

I would definetly suggest MM. I have palyed STH and it is a pretty good game and it does have a farming experance and all but if you don't sve the homeland, the game ends! I don't think you cna get married either. Again, I would definately suggest MM.

stargamergirl790 | Member | Joined: Jan 6th 2007
8 Posts | 58 Submissions

I like Magical Melody better you can do a lot more stuff then you can in save the homeland. Also save the home land is a lot older feeling....

mysteriouscorn | Member | Joined: Jul 2nd 2008
0 Posts | 22 Submissions

Next »
Terry« Previous
Ending

Click here for all our Harvest Moon: Magical Melody Questions

Add your answer
Please be as detailed as you can when making an answer. Answers that are too short or not descriptive are usually rejected.

Accept submission terms View Terms

You are not registered / logged in.
If you would like to receive an email to let you know if/when we have added this answer to the site please enter your email address. We will only use this address to email the confirmation for this answer.