Here is a proper list of variants and evolutions I haved discovered in my garden.
Feed it a nightshade berry. They can be obtained by waiting for a seed from seedos or whackin it out of him. Or they seed/berry can be purchased from costalots store after discovering the SEED. Outcome:Lackatoad
Buy a firebrand, direct the Taffly towards it, you may have to do thid more than once. When it has been lit on fire, put it out with a watering can, turn the firebrand off immediately after to prevent other pinatas from catching on fire.
Evolution: Buttercup Flowerhead changes it into a Candary.
Variant: Water Lily fh= pink.
Watercress fh= green.