Bronze 10 Times the Fun TrophyWin 10 ranked online matches
Bronze Against the Odds TrophyGet a base hit off of a legendary pitch in any single player game mode
Bronze Apocalyptic Success Bronze TrophyBreak the globe in the Times Square Home Run Pinball venue
Bronze Blammo! TrophyFill your Powerup Meter and successfully complete a Big Slam in any single player game mode
Bronze Burglar TrophySteal 3 bases in one game in any single player game mode
Bronze Can't Intimidate Me! TrophyGet a Wheelhouse Turbo x3 strike vs Legendary Batting Attributes in any single player game mode
Bronze Cross-Continental Success TrophyWin your first ranked match online
Bronze Happy New Years TrophyHit the New Year's Ball with a Big Blast in the Retro Times Square Home Run Pinball Venue
Bronze Japan Complete TrophyComplete the Japan portion of Become a Legend Mode
Bronze Legendary Strikeout TrophyStrike out Babe Ruth
Bronze Look Out Below! TrophyGet 5 Home Runs in a single game in any single player game mode
Bronze Mexico Complete TrophyComplete the Mexico portion of Become a Legend Mode
Bronze Perfection TrophyGet a shutout in a 5 inning game minimum in any single player game mode
Bronze Power Struggle TrophyWin a game on Super Hard in any single player game mode
Bronze Retro Times Square Master TrophyGet 1,000,000 points in the Retro Times Square Home Run Pinball venue
Bronze Shibuya Master TrophyGet 1,000,000 points in the Shibuya Home Run Pinball venue
Bronze Slay the Giant Brute TrophyHit the Giant Brute with a Big Blast in the Shibuya Home Run Pinball Venue
Bronze Steal Dave Winfield TrophyWin the Dave Winfield challenge in the Become a Legend Hall of Fame
Bronze Steal Ozzie Smith TrophyWin the Ozzie Smith challenge in the Become a Legend Hall of Fame
Bronze Steal Reggie Jackson TrophyWin the Reggie Jackson challenge in the Become a Legend Hall of Fame
Bronze Steal Ryne Sandberg TrophyWin the Ryne Sandberg challenge in the Become a Legend Hall of Fame
Bronze Steal Wade Boggs TrophyWin the Wade Boggs challenge in the Become a Legend Hall of Fame
Bronze Take that Blimp Down TrophyHit the Blimp with a Big Blast in the Las Vegas Home Run Pinball Venue
Bronze Taste of Power TrophyPerform your first Legendary Catch in any single player game mode
Bronze The Slam Dance TrophyStrike Out the Potential Home Run Hit on a Big Slam in any single player game mode
Bronze Times Square Master TrophyGet 1,000,000 points in the Times Square Home Run Pinball venue
Bronze Two for the Price of One TrophyPerform a Successful Double Steal in any single player game mode
Bronze Vegas Master TrophyGet 1,000,000 points in the Vegas Home Run Pinball venue
Silver Double the Fun TrophyGet 2,000,000 points in any Home Run Pinball venue while playing co-op
Silver Party Like it's 1881! TrophyGet a Grand Slam without using the Big Slam powerup in any single player game mode
Silver Penultimate Perfection TrophyIn a 5 inning (minimum) single player game, prevent the other team from getting an official hit
Silver Power Derby Winner TrophyCome out on top in the BIGS 2 Power Derby in Season mode
Gold Become a Legend TrophyComplete Become a Legend Mode
Gold Best Season Ever TrophyMatch all of the Legendary Milestones during a season in Season Mode
Gold Hit for the Cycle TrophyHit for the cycle in any single player game mode
Gold Textbook Perfection TrophyIn a 5 inning (minimum) single player game, prevent the other team from getting on base at all
Gold You are the Champions TrophyWin the World Series and get a season score of 1,000,000 or more at the end of a Season
Platinum Platinum Status TrophyBecome the greatest of all time