Your Account
    Log into your account here:
       Forgot Password

    Not registered? Sign Up for free
    Registration allows you to keep track of all your content and comments, save bookmarks, and post in all our forums.
Follow the dark path or use the light

Blood Brothers

Mimo_Pisani asks:
Added May 4th 2008, ID #117183

Blood Brothers

Hey guys, I'm at the point in gta IV were I have to choose between killin francis or his brother derek, I was wondering what will happen if I kill francis or if I kill derek what happens afterward?? Which is the best scenario?? Thanks

Comment:(May 11 2008) hey guys thanks for the responds now i have to kill playboy or dwayne which is the best one to do?? please help out thanks guys!


GTA 4 Guide
Grand Theft Auto 4 GuideOur complete guide to all the missions in GTA 4. Plus all 200 pigeon locations mapped and detailed. All 50 Stunt Jumps, mapped with descriptions on ..

Add your answer19 Answers

Best Answer

Chappie269 answered:
Added 5th May 2008, ID #252798

I chose to kill Francis so he can't continue to threaten you any longer. Francis is also hated by all his brothers so they don't care that he is dead even though the only one of them that ever finds out you killed him is Derek, but he is the one who asked you to do it so he thanks you for it. I have no idea what happens if you kill Derek but I'm sure you will attend his funeral the same as you attend the one for Francis but I think Francis will continue to threaten you and may even tell the rest of the family you killed Derek.

Showing all comments
Guest said: 20th Aug 2012 | REPORT
btw if u go to firefly island and go behind the bowling alley u will find a small picture of derrick and a secret machine gun which is on liberty city stories it holds 30 bullets and is one shot kill hope this helps
Guest said: 26th Nov 2015 | REPORT
Where is his picture

Other Answers

uranium answered:
Added 8th May 2008, ID #253375

The are two different endings in this game one is if you kill francis....derek kills your cousin but if you kill derek he kills kate your friend ... Or it's the other way around with derek or francis


nicko 9000 answered:
Added 9th May 2008, ID #253466

Kill derek.

If you kill francis, you wont be able to complete the game 100%, as you havent finished his missions.

TJR074 answered:
Added 10th May 2008, ID #253634

I agree, kill derek, you can go for the 100% completion rate and if you don't feel like dating kiki, he will also clear your wanted level for you. I only hate doing this cause I liked Derek more than Francis.

Nitrodude answered:
Added 19th May 2008, ID #255253

Kill playboy you will get his mansion... Kill dwayne you get nothin

Showing all comments
Guest said: 3rd Jun 2012 | REPORT
NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!! I killed Dwayne because i hadn't played GTA 4 in 2 months and forgot which character was who... I swear i'm extreeeemly temped to start a new game. (im about 85% done)
boxy_brown answered:
Added 27th May 2008, ID #256637

If you kill francis you will still get 100 % I promise because I killed him and I got 100 % for his mission progress

Alexzander answered:
Added 28th Jun 2008, ID #265195

I don't think it matters that much wich one you kill.

trisha911 answered:
Added 23rd Jul 2008, ID #270692

Just choose who you want to kill, Francis of Derek who do you hate more?
As for the Dwayne or Playboy problem kill Playboy, you get more stuff that way and I'm not just talking crib and clothes.

Showing all comments
Guest said: 17th Jun 2010 | REPORT
What other stuff do you get if you kill playboy?
towboy said: 5th Jun 2011 | REPORT
if you kill playboy dwyane will become your friend and send his gang out to help you in a tight squeeze
SUPERMAN5 answered:
Added 31st Oct 2008, ID #288613

It doesn't matter which one you kill.

Guest answered:
Added 5th Aug 2010, ID #346491

i killed Francis but derek has more funer missons like ill take her.

Guest answered:
Added 26th Aug 2010, ID #352109

if you kill playboy x then you can call derek for reinforsments and a savehouse

Guest answered:
Added 30th Aug 2010, ID #352983

Kill Playboy X he just leaves you, Derek komes ur homie and helps you bro

Guest answered:
Added 13th Nov 2010, ID #366721

Derek because Francis blackmails u

Guest answered:
Added 20th Feb 2011, ID #388238

Wat if you shoot a rocket at both of them

Showing all comments
Guest said: 28th Apr 2011 | REPORT
it restarts the mission i tried that to
Submission removed pending moderation
Guest answered:
Added 26th Nov 2011, ID #458874

I decided to kill plaboy he turned on his friend **** him and dwayne gives you back up wen you need and personaly with blood brothers I say the same because like ^he said you stay in contact with the family and bc francis turned on his own family that aint right homie
Phill the wolverine

Guest answered:
Added 11th Dec 2011, ID #462865

Kill playboy and kill derick

Guest answered:
Added 2nd Aug 2012, ID #527799

If you want to get 100 percent and a bit of extra cash kill derek on the blood brothers mission.First go onto the roof and then call francis he will pick up and offer you a pay rise if you kill derek accept the offer and then kill derek you will get and odd 20 grand but if you kill francis you get nothing.

Hope this helps

Guest answered:
Added 2nd Aug 2012, ID #527996



Add your answer

Please be as detailed as you can when making an answer. Answers that are too short or not descriptive are usually rejected.

Please do not use this box to ask a question, it will be rejected - this box is for answers ONLY. If you want to ask a question for this game, please use the ask a question box which is above on the right.

BB Codes Guide

Accept submission terms View Terms

You are not registered / logged in.
If you would like to ne notified if/when we have added this answer to the site please enter your email address.
We will only use this address to email the confirmation for this answer.


Related Items
Need Answers?
Ask a question for Grand Theft Auto 4

Your Question
Please give as much detail as possible.

You are not registered / logged in.
If you would like to receive an email to let you know if/when we have added this question to the site please enter your email address.

We will only use this address to email the confirmation for this question.

View Terms

Ask a question for a different game.