Your Account
    Log into your account here:
       Forgot Password

    Not registered? Sign Up for free
    Registration allows you to keep track of all your content and comments, save bookmarks, and post in all our forums.
Follow the dark path or use the light

Harvest Moon: Tree of Tranquility Pack Shot

Harvest Moon: Tree of Tranquility



Deavnl asks: Added Nov 19th 2008, ID #133156


I want to marry Gill, but whenever I give him the blue feather he says "Oh, a blue feather...?" >.>

Comment:(Nov 20 2008) nvm


Add your answer19 Answers for this Question
Best Answer
ChikaChan answered:
Added 5th Feb 2009, ID #300937
Yeah, I'm having th eexact same problem, (and ripping my hair out during the process) but ydolem is right.
Other Answers
ydolem answered:
Added 31st Dec 2008, ID #295879
Before you can marry anyone, you must complete the challenge/request that they give you. Gill's request is to find his lost diary. It is located near his house behind a bulletin board. You also have to complete ALL of the heart events. In order to get the "love confession" one, you have to talk to him before 10am and then meet him by Alan's Tree in Brownie Ranch.

muttluver answered:
Added 28th Jun 2009, ID #313808
I can't get behind the bulletin board, or I might be at the wrong one because I completed all of the events but I not sure what happened! Can anyone tell me where the bulletin board is?
Guest answered:
Added 15th Jun 2010, ID #332160
There is a challenge/request they give you at 6 hearts. For Gill, its to find his diary. For Gill, Im already at 10 hearts and I finished the challenge. But I still didnt marry him. His Diary is behind the bulletin board beside the tree where its close to going to the church. You can just go close to the bush and if you can see that you can press the A button, press A. And then youll find it, and read it. After that, give it to Gill. He will then get mad at you because you read it, but he will thank you for finding it. After that you can give him the blue feather and marry him.
Showing all comments
Guest said: 2nd Nov 2014 | REPORT
Ok , I did all that , but he still keeps saying " oh , is that a blue feather ?" I swear if I don't get the answer soon , I'm going to kill my self ! JK don't take that personally but seurioslly , I'm ripping my hair out !
Guest answered:
Added 22nd Jul 2010, ID #342433
okay so he gave me the gift but we still are at two hearts ?
how do I get to three I'm seriously paranoid I'm like stalking him .
Showing all comments
Guest said: 16th Jul 2014 | REPORT
You give him 2 gifts a day until he gives you a gift
Guest answered:
Added 31st Jul 2010, ID #345103
I ='m sorry if this doesn't help but it's by the bullitent by my the church under a tree
Guest answered:
Added 9th Aug 2010, ID #347817

Showing all comments
ItaKure said: 23rd Apr 2014 | REPORT
Give him his favorite gifts (Tomato Juice is the easiest)
Guest said: 6th Aug 2014 | REPORT
Talk to him every day, and give him items. Try to find his favourite items by trying new ones every time Smile
Guest answered:
Added 11th Aug 2010, ID #348496
you have to give him the stuff he likes everyday. the stuff he likes are lavender and any dishes with tomato. and talk to him once everyday other than giving him the present! i hope this helped!
Guest answered:
Added 21st Aug 2010, ID #350994
i can to marry gill but he didn't to marry beccasue he lose his dairy?
Showing all comments
Guest said: 6th Aug 2014 | REPORT
Every one has a special quest you must finish before you can marry them.
Guest answered:
Added 6th Nov 2010, ID #365332
the diary is by the church
Guest answered:
Added 24th Nov 2010, ID #368440
You know that little plaza area near Hamilton's house, the one with a few benches and a shipping bin? There's a bulletin board there with a map of Waffle Town. If you go down just below that bulletin board, near the path you take to get to the church, Gill's diary is hidden out in plain sight by the bushes below that bulletin board. It looks like a black square that doesn't belong there. Hope this helped! Smile
madgecual answered:
Added 26th May 2011, ID #407462
That means you didn't finish his request, or you didn't raise his heart level high enough.
Guest answered:
Added 25th Jun 2011, ID #415807
You can't marry him if you have not gotten all the rainbows
Showing all comments
Guest said: 25th Feb 2012 | REPORT
really you can get married before you get all of the rainbows i know because i did.
Guest said: 6th Aug 2014 | REPORT
Yes there are two paths you can take. The family path, and the rainbow path.
You can do whichever one first it doesnt matter.
Guest answered:
Added 22nd Aug 2011, ID #434891
His heart level is 10
Found his diary
We're going steady

Why can't I marry him?!!??!
Showing all comments
ItaKure said: 23rd Apr 2014 | REPORT
You may need the Love Event which should have happened at 7 Hearts. If you declared your love for him at that event then he should accept the Blue Feather
Guest answered:
Added 17th Jan 2012, ID #474255
Ok if any of you know where yolanda hangs out every day, you should because theres a shipping bin there, and since you all seem to be dead set on marrying gill, you would know that he lives right next to a courtyard area, go there and look over the fence on the far side, that is the 'behind the sign' that everyone is talking about, then you can just walk around and press a until you find it, if your still unsure where I'm talking about I suggest you look for the4 path that leads direstly to the church and then face the village

(sorry for my bad spelling)

Hope I helped

Guest answered:
Added 23rd May 2012, ID #509332
Search the grassy area behind the courtyard that is right across from Sundae Inn and you'll find it, it's not literally right behind the board (like I thought) hope this clears things up more for those of you like me -w-
Guest answered:
Added 9th Aug 2012, ID #530637
My sister has ten hearts for Gill, completed all 5 rainbows, and has found Gill's diary for him. But Gill still won't accept the blue feather. Does anyone know why this is?
Guest answered:
Added 13th Oct 2012, ID #544338
Did you get his diary yet? It's in front of the inn and behind where the shipping bin is

Guest answered:
Added 6th Mar 2013, ID #575247
Do you have a double bed?? He won't marry you if there is no room for him to sleep...
Showing all comments
ItaKure said: 23rd Apr 2014 | REPORT
That Doesn't make sense, when I married my bed was upgraded to the Double Bed.

Add your answer

Please be as detailed as you can when making an answer. Answers that are too short or not descriptive are usually rejected.

Please do not use this box to ask a question, it will be rejected - this box is for answers ONLY. If you want to ask a question for this game, please use the ask a question box which is above on the right.

BB Codes Guide

Accept submission terms View Terms

You are not registered / logged in.
If you would like to ne notified if/when we have added this answer to the site please enter your email address.
We will only use this address to email the confirmation for this answer.


More Questions
Need Answers?
Ask a question for Harvest Moon: Tree of Tranquility

Question Guidelines

Your Question (short version)

Question Description (more details)

Please complete both boxes

You are not registered / logged in.
If you would like to receive an email to let you know if/when we have added this question to the site please enter your email address.

We will only use this address to email the confirmation for this question.

View Terms

Ask a question for a different game.
Game Talk
Top 10 SideKick Characters
Top 10 SideKick Characters
Top 10 Best Video Game Stories
Top 10 Best Video Game Stories
VR Gaming in 2017
VR Gaming in 2017
Ghost Recon: Wildlands BETA access
January Game Releases 2017
Vote for Playstation Game of the Year
Finalists announced for The Steam Awards
Christmas deals and giveaways for World of Warships
Battlefield 1 Giant's Shadow Release and Update
First Major Update for Pokemon Go