The following wrestlers can be unlocked in Exhibition mode by completing the corresponding task in Story mode (Style points earnt in Exhibition mode will also count).
Earn 200,000 Style points
Unlock Don West:
Earn 260,000 Style points
Unlock Benny the Clown:
Earn 350,000 Style points
Unlock 'Last Laugh' Lenny:
Earn 400,000 Style points.
Unlock Afro Thunder:
Earn 750,000 Style points.
Unlock Brother Ray:
Defeat Team 3D in Story mode.
Unlock Sonjay Dutt:
Defeat Sonjay Dutt in Story mode.
Unlock Black Machismo:
Defeat Black Machismo in Story mode.
Unlock Jeff Jarrett:
Defeat Jarrett in Story mode - Part 6.
Defeat Abyss in Story mode - Part 6.
Unlock Eric Young:
After getting partnered with Eric Young win a Tag Team match with him.
Unlock Jay Lethal:
Defeat Jay Lethal in your TNA Tryout Gauntlet match.
Complete Story mode and Suicide becomes unlocked after the credits have finished.
Win the Tomko and AJ Styles Tag match in Story mode.
Unlock Mike Tenay:
Added by: Sanzano Sep 16th 2008, ID#876