Bronze A Pitcher's Best FriendTurn a double play on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game.
Bronze A VirtueFace 10 pitches as the batter on Pro or higher in a non-simulated game.
Bronze A Whole New YouChoose a signature batting stance or pitching delivery in My Player or Create Player.
Bronze Count ItComplete and win a ranked match.
Bronze DominationStrikeout 200 batters with your profile.
Bronze Don't Call It a ComebackWin after being down by 4 after the 6th inning on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game.
Bronze Down But Not OutGet a hit with 2 strikes on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game.
Bronze Grab Some PineGet a strikeout to end the inning on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game.
Bronze High CrimesRob a Home Run on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game.
Bronze HurlersUnlock 20 pitcher cards.
Bronze I Came, I Saw...Hit a Walk-off Home Run on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game.
Bronze It's Never Too LateGet a 2-out RBI Hit on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game.
Bronze Keep on Truckin'Truck the Catcher and score on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game.
Bronze King of the HillGet to the top of the Best of the Best ladder in Home Run Derby Mode.
Bronze Learning the RopesAchieve gold in all the drills.
Bronze My Fellow ManComplete and win an online league game.
Bronze One Man ShowThrow a Perfect Game or a No-Hitter on Pro or higher in a 9 inning game, in a non-simulated game.
Bronze Run the RiskSteal a base after the 6th inning tied or down by 1 run on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game.
Bronze State Farm - The Road to VictoryGet 3 consecutive batters on base on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game.
Bronze Still KickingStrike out a batter with a pitcher who has low composure on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game.
Bronze StoogesStrikeout all three hitters in the inning on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game.
Bronze SwingersUnlock 25 hitter cards.
Bronze The Road to GreatnessComplete and win 3 ranked matches in a row.
Bronze The Spice of LifeComplete 10 online matches using 10 different teams.
Bronze The Team to BeatBeat the New York Yankees in a completed online match.
Bronze This is Why I'm HereBe successful in a major-league clutch moment in My Player Mode.
Bronze Thou Shall NotThrow out a runner stealing a base on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game.
Bronze Time to Run for MayorHit 3 Home Runs in a single game with the same player on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game.
Bronze To the RescueBring in a pitcher, get a save with the tying run on base on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game.
Bronze Trifectas MaximusThrow a MAX pitch 3 consecutive times with Total Control on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game.
Silver A Day in the LifePlay a game of MLB Today.
Silver Booked a TicketClinch a Postseason Berth in Franchise Mode. (play at least 20 games)
Silver Mid-Summer ClassicPlay the All-Star game in MLB Today.
Silver One and OPlay and win opening day in Franchise Mode.
Silver Remember MeBreak a record in Franchise Mode. (play at least 20 games)
Silver The CallGet called up to the Majors in My Player Mode.
Silver The GoalAccomplish a Team Season Goal in My Player Mode.
Silver The HallMake the Hall of Fame in My Player Mode.
Silver The StarMake the All-Star team in My Player mode.
Silver The StartGet your player's overall rating to 65 in My Player Mode.
Silver The TopBecome the #1 ranked player in your My Player organization.
Silver The TruthGet your player's overall rating to 85 in My Player Mode.
Silver What's Your Ring Size?Win a World Series in Franchse Mode. (play at least 20 games)
Gold ProductionDrive in 250 RBI with your profile.
Platinum A Job Well DoneUnlock all Trophies