Bronze 99 Scalps TrophyDeliver 99 headshots (ranked play counts).
Bronze Act I TrophyComplete Act I.
Bronze Act II TrophyComplete Act II.
Bronze Act III TrophyComplete Act III.
Bronze Act IV TrophyComplete Act IV.
Bronze Arkansas Fried Rooster Bronze TrophyBlow up 10 chickens with dynamite.
Bronze Between Hay and Grass TrophyFinish the game on at least medium difficulty.
Bronze Boy Scout TrophyFinish one side quest.
Bronze Catcher in the Rye TrophyOn chapter II, in the field, kill enemy soldiers using knives without being detected.
Bronze Crime Does Pay TrophyWin 5 rounds as an Outlaw (ranked only).
Bronze Crowbait TrophyFinish the game on at least easy difficulty.
Bronze D-Day TrophyOn chapter I, destroy all rafts before they land.
Bronze Drive-By TrophyKill a total of 5 enemies while horseback (ranked play counts).
Bronze Fireworks TrophyShoot 2 enemy dynamite sticks in mid air.
Bronze Frag Steal TrophyKill all enemies in a single Cooperative Concentration Mode.
Bronze High Noon TrophyKill 4 enemies between 12:00 p.m. and 12:15 p.m. (local time, ranked play counts).
Bronze Jack of All Trades TrophyPlay a full game with each class (ranked only).
Bronze Mad Carpenter TrophyKill 5 enemies with a chair.
Bronze Man of the Hood TrophyOn chapter XII, playing as Thomas, use only bow throughout the whole level.
Bronze Mayhem TrophyOn chapter III, kill 20 armed enemies while riding the stagecoach.
Bronze None Shall Hide TrophyShoot an enemy through a wall.
Bronze Pistol Expert TrophyKill 250 People using pistols (ranked play counts).
Bronze Quick Hands TrophyKill 7 people during one concentration mode.
Bronze Quite a Ride TrophyOn chapter IX, on the lift, destroy everything that is thrown at you.
Bronze Rifle Expert TrophyKill 250 People using rifles (ranked play counts).
Bronze Rowing-Race Cheater TrophyOn chapter XI, kill all the Indians during canoe chase.
Bronze Sharpshooter Destruction TrophyOn chapter IV, playing as Thomas, kill sharpshooters in 10 seconds.
Bronze Sharpshooter Distraction TrophyOn chapter IV, playing as Ray, kill sharpshooters without Thomas' help.
Bronze Shield of Hope TrophyFinish all side quests.
Bronze Shotgun Expert TrophyKill 250 People using shotguns (ranked play counts).
Bronze Tin Star TrophyWin 5 rounds as a Lawman (ranked only).
Bronze Unforgiven TrophyKill 10 enemies as an invincible wanted (ranked only).
Bronze Vindicator TrophyKill a total of 30 enemies with movable gatling.
Bronze Welcome to the Frontier TrophyFinish a full Wild West Legends game (ranked only).
Bronze Well TrophyBuy 20 second level and 10 third level upgrades (ranked only).
Bronze Yankee Cow TrophyOn chapter II, don't kill the cow.
Silver Been There, Done That TrophyPlay a full Wild West Legends game on every level (both match and revenge match count; ranked only).
Silver Curly Wolf TrophyFinish the game on hard difficulty.
Silver Gotta Catch'em All TrophyCollect all secrets.
Silver Magnificent Thirteen TrophyUnlock all classes (ranked only).
Silver On the Right Track TrophyCollect a total of $200 000 (ranked play counts) to unlock silver weapons in multiplayer.
Silver Ray's Story TrophyFinish every chapter playing as Ray.
Silver Thomas' Story TrophyFinish every chapter playing as Thomas.
Silver Untouchable TrophyFinish any chapter, except for VI and VIII, without getting severely wounded.
Gold Forgiveth Me, Lord TrophyKill 2000 enemies (ranked play counts).
Gold Goldrush! TrophyCollect a total of $1,000,000 (ranked play counts) to unlock golden weapons in multiplayer.
Gold Old West Legend TrophyFinish the game on very hard difficulty.
Platinum Ace of Spades TrophyCollect all other trophies.