The most difficult items to create are the Legend Items which there are 11 in total, these are: Magic, Gnome, Mermaid, Nessie, Pegasus, Ghost, Angel, Frankenstein's Monster, Treasure Map, Light Sword, and UFO.
To create the Legend Items will require 40 elements. A common ingredient many of the Legend Items require is a Story which is a series of events or incidents told via campfire, book, cave drawing or laborious voice over.
Common Ingredients
Story = Human + Campfire
Campfire = Fire + Wood
Wood = Axe + Tree
Tree= Plant + Big
Legend Items Ingredients
Magic
Magic = Life + Rainbow
Rainbow
Rainbow = Water + Sun
Gnome
'A protector of gardens who also happens to be an insurance salesman'.
Gnome = Story + Garden
Garden = House + Plant
Mermaid
'A woman who has a beautiful singing voice and a fish tail instead of legs'.
Mermaid = Magic + Fish
Fish = Water + Animal
Nessie
'A shared hallucination by the visitors to Loch Ness'.
Nessie = Story + Lake
Lake = Water + Pond
Pegasus
'A winged hornless unicorn'.
Pegasus = Horse + Sky
Sky = Sun + Moon
Moon = Earth + Night
Night = Time + Day
Day = Time + Sun
Ghost
'Life after death, sometimes as a translucent body, and often on the receiving end of busts'.
Ghost = Story + Grave
Grave = Earth + Corpse
Corpse = Human + Time
Angel
'Divine Servant of God'.
Angel = Human + Light
Light
There is no combination to get Light, it is unlocked through Gameplay progress.
Frankenstein’s Monster
'The tragic result of a mad scientist’s quest to conquer death'.
Frankenstein’s Monster = Corpse + Electricity
Electricity = Storm + Science
Science = Human + Universe
Storm = Cloud + Cloud
Cloud = Water + Sky
Treasure Map
'Valuable pieces of paper that can possibly lead to riches, but more likely mutiny and/or death'.
Treasure Map = Island + Map
Map = Paper + Continent
Paper = Wood + Machine
Machine = Tool + Tool
Tool = Human + Stone
Light Sword
'An Elegant Weapon for a More Civilized Age'.
Light Sword = Light + Sword
Sword = Blade + Wood
UFO
'Objects prone to close encounters'.
UFO = Sky + Alien
Alien = Life + Mars
Mars = Planet + Rust
Rust = Oxygen + Metal
Oxygen = Sun + Algae
Algae = Water + Plant