The following animals can be found at the indicated location or the surrounding area. If they still do not appear go to the farthest away town (Empire or Dodge) and return.
Near the bridge in Dodge.
Near the mine (not Magruder's). It roams with the other buffalo.
Same place the White Buffalo was, usually behind the mine.
Near Piper lake, usually by the waterfall.
Go to where Magruder's mine is located. Stand at it with your back to it. To your left is the train tunnel, and to your right is the path to the Indian hunter. Go through the middle path to find him.
Near Empire. The map will show you it's location. You do not have to use an arrow to kill him.
Added by: Sanzano Aug 15th 2011, ID#7632