Bronze Advanced CooperationWith different users controlling the pitcher and fielders, complete a strike 'em out throw 'em out double play.
Bronze CooperationWin a co-op game.
Bronze Daddy Long LegsIn any season mode, hit a triple on Father's Day.
Bronze Day at the BeachHit a Home Run into the sand at Petco Park.
Bronze Dig that long ballIn any mode (excluding HRD) hit a Home Run with a pitcher.
Bronze ExperiencedAccumulate 100 XP across any online game modes.
Bronze Fill'er UpAfter falling behind in the count 0-2 work back to a full count. Must be completed vs. the CPU with both pitching and batting set to All-Star or higher difficulty.
Bronze Have a CoW Man!Compete in the Challenge of the Week in back to back weeks.
Bronze Ice ColdHit a Home Run to dead center in Coors Field.
Bronze Lean On MePick off the CPU runner on 1st.
Bronze Momma's BoyIn any season mode, hit a Home Run on Mother's Day with a pink bat.
Bronze Patience...Draw a 4 pitch walk in any mode. Must be completed vs. the CPU on All-Star or higher difficulty.
Bronze Pesky...In any single at bat, see 10 or more pitches. Must be completed vs. the CPU on All-Star or higher difficulty.
Bronze Poor Billy...Win a game on an error.
Bronze Salute the TroopsWin a game using the Padres while wearing Camo Jerseys.
Bronze Sell Your BodyMake a diving catch in foul territory for an out.
Bronze Splash Down IIHit a Home Run into the hot tub in Chase field.
Bronze Stay on TargetAt Target Field, land your foul ball or tailing Home Run on the Target sign down the right field line.
Bronze Stone HandsMake 5 or more errors in a single game.
Bronze Strong ArmThrow the ball into the stands when attempting to throw out a runner at 1st.
Bronze Swim With The FishesHit a Home Run into the Ray's aquarium.
Bronze The BaconIn RttS, earn more than 20,000,000 over the course of your career.
Bronze The Billy GoatIn Season or Franchise mode, win the World Series as the Cubs. Good luck, you're going to need it! Must be full 9 inning games, simulating of World Series games will invalidate the trophy.
Silver Batting Performance EvaluatedAs a Batter in RttS, have 3 or more 'Good' or better At Bats in a single game at the MLB Level.
Silver ChallengerPlace in the top 33% in any single week of Challenge of the Week.
Silver Pitching Performance EvaluatedAs a Pitcher in RttS, in a single game, face 6 or more consecutive batters achieving a 'Good' or better rating at the MLB Level.
Silver Running Down a DreamIn a single game, steal 3rd twice. Must be completed vs. the CPU.
Silver SeasonedAchieve an All-Star rank across all online game modes.
Gold Beat LABeat the Dodgers. Must be completed vs. the CPU with both pitching and batting set to Legend. RttS excluded.
Gold InsiderIn any mode get an inside the park Home Run. Must be completed vs. the CPU.
Gold Peak TrainingIn RTTS, reach level 5 in all training modes as a pitcher or a batter.
Gold PsychicWith Guess Pitch on, in any mode, correctly guess 10 pitches in a row (Location OR Pitch) vs. the CPU on All-Star or higher difficulty.
Gold Today... I am the greatestIn any mode, with any single player, accumulate 130 or more stolen bases in a single Season.
Gold Yankees 'Inhale Deeply Through The Mouth'!Beat the Yankees. Must be completed vs. the CPU with both pitching and batting set to Legend. RttS excluded.
Platinum 100% ClearThis is the platinum trophy and is unlocked automatically when all trophies have been unlocked.