Bronze A Good StartStrike out 15 batters in a single game in any mode versus the CPU.
Bronze Around the WorldPlay a game in every Major League stadium.
Bronze Back-To-BackHit back-to-back home runs in any mode (Excludes HRD and Practice).
Bronze Basket CaseIn any mode, hit a home run into the basket that lines the wall at Wrigley Field.
Bronze Bobbying For ApplesIn any mode, hit a home run that hits the center-field apple at Citi-Field.
Bronze Call ItCall a 'Quality Start' as a catcher in any RTTS game.
Bronze Caught Lookin'Strike out a CPU player looking on All-Star or higher difficulty.
Bronze ContenderMake the postseason in Franchise or Season Mode (without simulating more than 82 games.)
Bronze CustomizerCustomize any team's audio in Sounds of the Show.
Bronze DirectorCreate and save a highlight movie using the Movie Maker feature.
Bronze King Of The HillIn any mode, hit a home run to dead center in Minute Maid Park.
Bronze Make The Call... AgainGet called up to a Major League team before the end of your second year in RTTS.
Bronze Monster KillerHit two home runs over the Green Monster in any single game played in Boston (Excludes HRD and Practice).
Bronze On the RocksIn any mode, hit a home run into the rocks in left-center in Anaheim.
Bronze Online GamerReach 100 MLB Points.
Bronze Pop OutWith the bases loaded in the 9th, get an infield pop-up to end the game.
Bronze RTTS Back-To-BackHit consecutive home runs in one game with your RTTS Player.
Bronze RTTS Road WarriorWin 8 out of 10 starts on the road in RTTS on All-Star or higher difficulty.
Bronze RTTS: The FutureGet invited to the All-Star Week Futures Game at any position in RTTS.
Bronze Sawed OffIn any mode, break the hitter's bat.
Bronze Scrap MetalIn any mode, hit a home run into the Western Metal Supply Company building in San Diego.
Bronze Sight SeeingIn any mode, hit a home run off of the glass in center field at Rogers Centre.
Bronze Sim GameDo not allow a run in any RTTS simulated game training.
Bronze Splish SplashIn any mode, hit a home run over the RF wall into the water of the San Francisco bay.
Bronze Take It backRob a home run in any game mode.
Bronze Timing Is EverythingCall a pitchout on a steal attempt in any RTTS game.
Bronze Tres BienIn any mode, have a three-pitch inning with any pitcher versus the CPU.
Silver Crazy EightsIn the Knockout Pitch Training or Practice Mode, knock out all eight sections in eight pitches.
Silver HRDHit 30 or more home runs with any single player in HRD.
Silver Mr. OctoberAchieve the following stats with any RTTS player: .350 AVG, .450 OBP, .755 SLG.
Silver Online FameReach 500 MLB Points.
Silver Out PitchIn any one-player mode, with any pitcher, strike out the side using the same pitch for each 'out' pitch.
Silver Pennant RaceCapture a division title. (Simulating any games in the postseason will negate the trophy. Cannot simulate more than 82 games prior to making the postseason.)
Silver Professional TrainerComplete a RTTS batting session without receiving a single attribute penalty.
Silver Road WarriorHave a 10-game road winning streak. (Simulating or fast-forwarding will restart the streak.)
Silver RTTS DerbyGet invited to the HRD with any RTTS player.
Silver Triple PlayTurn a triple play in any mode versus the CPU.
Silver UnassistedTurn an unassisted double play in RTTS.
Gold Hamilwho?In HRD, hit 29 or more home runs with any player in a single round.
Gold Much Cooler This Year...Join and complete an online league. (Must play 60% of the games).
Gold Victory Is MINE!Win the World Series. (Simulating any games in the postseason will negate the trophy. Cannot simulate more than 82 games prior to making the postseason.)
Platinum 100% ClearThis is the platinum trophy and is unlocked automatically when all trophies have been unlocked.