If you're having a hard time not using any strikes against Festus on Week 9 (which unlocks Bob Orton), you should only stick to quick grapples. Just pull the right stick to any direction (and alternate it) to do any quick grapple. If Ted DiBiase steals your title, then that is a signal to do a few more quick grapples and pin Festus for the win. You should obtain Bob Orton this way. Do not use the title belt, do diving attacks and attacks with the SQUARE button. That's all.
to unlock this first time in the caw rtw, do edges rtw first. you will unlock mr macmahon as a playable superstar in week 11 if you put hhh through a table. then, go to the caw rtw and in week 5 spend 1 minute outside the ring to unlock mr macmahon in a suit. complete the caw's rtw to unlock him in a chicken head, the same one he made you wear at the elimination chamber.