Its easy just make sure you have no offsides. Play PR Middle, Right, or left (don't play blocks, then the guys come in and guard the punter more carefully.) and choose a fast guy. Then go to the side out of the reach of the blocker and start running. When he says "HIKE!" just run at him, they don't try to get you and you can either:
1)Go in front and when he kicks it, use [Y] to block it OR 2)Tackle the punter or use the hit stick.
Get you Quarterback on Target - WROA0R Use this Madden card and your Quarterback will have 100% accuracy for all of the current half.
Get your Quarterback to make no mistakes - XL7SP1 Use this Madden card and your Quarterback will not throw an interception or fumble the ball for all of the current half. Screw up your opponents passes - 5LAWO0 Use this Madden card and your opposition will just be able to throw high in the air passes, you should find it more easy to intercept those passes.